SteelWT in tension

A WT brace under tension and a moment compressing its stem, AISC 360-22 F9 resistance, CSA S16 Cl. 13.9. Check a WT brace under a factored tension and a moment that puts its stem in compression. The slenderness and the gross section's yield are CSA S16's; the moment resistance is AISC 360-22 F9's yield, lateral-torsional buckling and stem local buckling; and the tension and moment are combined by S16 Cl. 13.9.

CA$4.00 for this report, or Pro

PASS Governing: Slenderness, y axis, D/C 0.16, S16 Cl. 10.4.2.24 of 4 checks below pass

d = 456 mm b = 304 mm w = 15.9 mm x
The WT's cross-section to scale.

Given

Jump to results

Type any value, everything below recomputes. Hover or tap a symbol to trace it.

Loads
changed from the declared value TfT_{f} kN\mathrm{kN}0-50,000
changed from the declared value MfxM_{\mathrm{fx}} kN⋅m\mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}0-10,000
Section
changed from the declared value
changed from the declared value FyF_{y} MPa\mathrm{MPa}150-700
Bracing
changed from the declared value LxL_{x} mm\mathrm{mm}100-30,000
changed from the declared value LyL_{y} mm\mathrm{mm}100-30,000

Title block

Optional. Printed in the title block of the PDF.

Checks

All 4 checks pass. Largest D/C 0.16, Slenderness, y axis.

Show all 4 checks

! marks a check that passes with D/C at or above 0.95: close to its limit. The band is a site convention, not a code limit.

Slenderness

Check D/C Utilisation Result
Slenderness, x axisS16 Cl. 10.4.2.2λx≤300⇒20.98≤300\htmlClass{sym-lambda_x}{\lambda_{x}} \leq 300 \quad \Rightarrow \quad \htmlClass{sym-lambda_x}{20.98} \leq 300 0.07 PASS
Slenderness, y axisS16 Cl. 10.4.2.2λy≤300⇒47.85≤300\htmlClass{sym-lambda_y}{\lambda_{y}} \leq 300 \quad \Rightarrow \quad \htmlClass{sym-lambda_y}{47.85} \leq 300 0.16 PASS

Strength

Check D/C Utilisation Result
Combined tension and bendingS16 Cl. 13.9.1Ia≤1⇒0.04451≤1\htmlClass{sym-I_a}{I_{a}} \leq 1 \quad \Rightarrow \quad \htmlClass{sym-I_a}{0.04451} \leq 1 0.04 PASS
Bending with tension reliefS16 Cl. 13.9.3 b), S at the stem tipIb≤1⇒−0.01988≤1\htmlClass{sym-I_b}{I_{b}} \leq 1 \quad \Rightarrow \quad \htmlClass{sym-I_b}{-0.01988} \leq 1 -0.02 PASS

Results

Quantity Description Value Unit
Tr\htmlClass{sym-T_r}{T_{r}} Tensile resistance, gross section 4504 kN\mathrm{kN}
Mrx\htmlClass{sym-M_rx}{M_{\mathrm{rx}}} Moment resistance about x 223.6 kN⋅m\mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}
Also worth checking
  • Yielding of the tee under service loads (Cl. 13.5 a) and 13.6.1 e)): the moment resistance takes up to 1.6 M_y
  • Block shear and net section fracture at the connection (Cl. 13.2 a) ii) and iii)): the tensile resistance is the gross section's yield
  • A moment that puts the stem in tension: refused as an input, so the tee's other flexural limit states (F9.2 and F9.3 with the stem in tension) are not taken
  • The tee's S16 class (Cl. 11.2, Table 2: a stem past 340/sqrt(F_y) is Class 4) and S16's own tee resistances, Cl. 13.5 c) and 13.6.1 e): the moment resistance is AISC 360-22 F9's, with the stem classed by AISC Table B4.1b case 14, as the rational method Cl. 13.6.1 e) allows
  • The inelastic lateral-torsional range of Cl. 13.6.1 e) for a Class 1 to 3 tee, which F9-13's M_n = M_cr <= M_y does not have: F9-13 is taken whole
  • A truss tension chord (Cl. 15.2.7, L/r not over 240) or an open-web joist bottom chord (Cl. 16.5.5.1): the 300 limit is Cl. 10.4.2.2's for other tension members
  • Compression in the member under load reversal (Cl. 13.3, 13.8) and the seismic requirements for braces (Cl. 27)
  • Bending about the weak axis, and web shear
  • The connection, including the bolts and shear lag

Derivation

1.1Resistance factor
ϕ=0.9(Resistance factor | S16 Cl. 13.1)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-phi}{\phi} &= 0.9 \quad \left(\text{Resistance factor | S16 Cl. 13.1}\right) \end{aligned}
1.2Steel modulus

S16 Cl. 3.2, E = 200 000 MPa

E=200000 MPa\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-E}{E} &= 200000\ \mathrm{MPa} \end{aligned}
1.3Depth
d=456 mm(Depth of section or height of vertical leg)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-d}{d} &= 456\ \mathrm{mm} \quad \left(\text{Depth of section or height of vertical leg}\right) \end{aligned}
1.4Flange width
b=304 mm(Width of flange or horizontal leg)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-b}{b} &= 304\ \mathrm{mm} \quad \left(\text{Width of flange or horizontal leg}\right) \end{aligned}
1.5Flange thickness
t=23.9 mm(Thickness of flange)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-t}{t} &= 23.9\ \mathrm{mm} \quad \left(\text{Thickness of flange}\right) \end{aligned}
1.6Stem thickness
w=15.9 mm(Thickness of web)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-w}{w} &= 15.9\ \mathrm{mm} \quad \left(\text{Thickness of web}\right) \end{aligned}
1.7Gross area
A0=14300 mm2(Cross-sectional area)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-A_0}{A_{0}} &= 14300\ \mathrm{mm}^{2} \quad \left(\text{Cross-sectional area}\right) \end{aligned}
1.8Centroid from the flange face
yc=122 mm(Vertical distance between centroid and outside face of flange orhorizontal leg)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-y_c}{y_{c}} &= 122\ \mathrm{mm} \quad \left(\text{Vertical distance between centroid and outside face of flange orhorizontal leg}\right) \end{aligned}
1.9Moment of inertia about x
Ix=2.92×108 mm4(Moment of inertia about axis XX)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-I_x}{I_{x}} &= 2.92 \times 10^{8}\ \mathrm{mm}^{4} \quad \left(\text{Moment of inertia about axis XX}\right) \end{aligned}
1.10Moment of inertia about y
Iy=5.61×107 mm4(Moment of inertia about axis YY)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-I_y}{I_{y}} &= 5.61 \times 10^{7}\ \mathrm{mm}^{4} \quad \left(\text{Moment of inertia about axis YY}\right) \end{aligned}
1.11Torsional constant
J=2.08×106 mm4(St-Venant torsional constant)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-J}{J} &= 2.08 \times 10^{6}\ \mathrm{mm}^{4} \quad \left(\text{St-Venant torsional constant}\right) \end{aligned}
1.12Radius of gyration about x
rx=143 mm(Radius of gyration about axis XX)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-r_x}{r_{x}} &= 143\ \mathrm{mm} \quad \left(\text{Radius of gyration about axis XX}\right) \end{aligned}
1.13Radius of gyration about y
ry=62.7 mm(Radius of gyration about axis YY)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-r_y}{r_{y}} &= 62.7\ \mathrm{mm} \quad \left(\text{Radius of gyration about axis YY}\right) \end{aligned}
1.14Elastic modulus, stem tip
Sxc=874000 mm3(Elastic section modulus about axis XX)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-S_xc}{S_{\mathrm{xc}}} &= 874000\ \mathrm{mm}^{3} \quad \left(\text{Elastic section modulus about axis XX}\right) \end{aligned}
2.1Slenderness ratio about x

S16 Cl. 10.4.1, L/r for a member in tension

λx=Lxrx=3000 mm143 mm=20.98\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-lambda_x}{\lambda_{x}} &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L_x}{L_{x}}}{\htmlClass{sym-r_x}{r_{x}}} \\ &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L_x}{3000\ \mathrm{mm}}}{\htmlClass{sym-r_x}{143\ \mathrm{mm}}} \\ &= 20.98 \end{aligned}
2.2Slenderness ratio about y

S16 Cl. 10.4.1, L/r for a member in tension

λy=Lyry=3000 mm62.7 mm=47.85\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-lambda_y}{\lambda_{y}} &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L_y}{L_{y}}}{\htmlClass{sym-r_y}{r_{y}}} \\ &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L_y}{3000\ \mathrm{mm}}}{\htmlClass{sym-r_y}{62.7\ \mathrm{mm}}} \\ &= 47.85 \end{aligned}
2.3Tensile resistance

S16 Cl. 13.2 a) i), gross section yield only; the connection's block shear and net section fracture (a) ii), iii)) are not checked here

Tr=ϕ⋅A0⋅Fy=0.9⋅14300 mm2⋅350 MPa=4504 kN\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-T_r}{T_{r}} &= \htmlClass{sym-phi}{\phi} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-A_0}{A_{0}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-F_y}{F_{y}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-phi}{0.9} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-A_0}{14300\ \mathrm{mm}^{2}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-F_y}{350\ \mathrm{MPa}} \\ &= 4504\ \mathrm{kN} \end{aligned}
3.1Yielding resistance

AISC 360-22 F9-1, F9-3 and F9-4, M_p = M_y for a tee stem in compression

Mrx1=ϕ⋅Sxc⋅Fy=0.9⋅874000 mm3⋅350 MPa=275.3 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_rx1}{M_{\mathrm{rx}1}} &= \htmlClass{sym-phi}{\phi} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-S_xc}{S_{\mathrm{xc}}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-F_y}{F_{y}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-phi}{0.9} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-S_xc}{874000\ \mathrm{mm}^{3}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-F_y}{350\ \mathrm{MPa}} \\ &= 275.3\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
3.2Lateral-torsional buckling parameter

AISC 360-22 F9-12, stem in compression

B=(−2.3)⋅dLy⋅IyJ=(−2.3)⋅456 mm3000 mm⋅5.61×107 mm42.08×106 mm4=−1.816\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-B}{B} &= \left(-2.3\right) \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-d}{d}}{\htmlClass{sym-L_y}{L_{y}}} \cdot \sqrt{\frac{\htmlClass{sym-I_y}{I_{y}}}{\htmlClass{sym-J}{J}}} \\ &= \left(-2.3\right) \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-d}{456\ \mathrm{mm}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L_y}{3000\ \mathrm{mm}}} \cdot \sqrt{\frac{\htmlClass{sym-I_y}{5.61 \times 10^{7}\ \mathrm{mm}^{4}}}{\htmlClass{sym-J}{2.08 \times 10^{6}\ \mathrm{mm}^{4}}}} \\ &= -1.816 \end{aligned}
3.3Elastic lateral-torsional buckling moment

AISC 360-22 F9-10

Mcr=1.95⋅ELy⋅Iy⋅J⋅(B+1+B2)=1.95⋅200000 MPa3000 mm⋅5.61×107 mm4⋅2.08×106 mm4⋅((−1.816)+1+(−1.816)2)=361.1 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_cr}{M_{\mathrm{cr}}} &= 1.95 \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-E}{E}}{\htmlClass{sym-L_y}{L_{y}}} \cdot \sqrt{\htmlClass{sym-I_y}{I_{y}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-J}{J}} \cdot \left(\htmlClass{sym-B}{B} + \sqrt{1 + \htmlClass{sym-B}{B}^{2}}\right) \\ &= 1.95 \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-E}{200000\ \mathrm{MPa}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L_y}{3000\ \mathrm{mm}}} \cdot \sqrt{\htmlClass{sym-I_y}{5.61 \times 10^{7}\ \mathrm{mm}^{4}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-J}{2.08 \times 10^{6}\ \mathrm{mm}^{4}}} \cdot \left(\left(\htmlClass{sym-B}{-1.816}\right) + \sqrt{1 + \left(\htmlClass{sym-B}{-1.816}\right)^{2}}\right) \\ &= 361.1\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
3.4Lateral-torsional buckling resistance

AISC 360-22 F9-13, M_n = M_cr <= M_y

Mrx2=ϕ⋅min⁡(Mcr,Sxc⋅Fy)=0.9⋅min⁡(361.1 kN⋅m,874000 mm3⋅350 MPa)=275.3 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_rx2}{M_{\mathrm{rx}2}} &= \htmlClass{sym-phi}{\phi} \cdot \min\left(\htmlClass{sym-M_cr}{M_{\mathrm{cr}}}, \htmlClass{sym-S_xc}{S_{\mathrm{xc}}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-F_y}{F_{y}}\right) \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-phi}{0.9} \cdot \min\left(\htmlClass{sym-M_cr}{361.1\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}, \htmlClass{sym-S_xc}{874000\ \mathrm{mm}^{3}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-F_y}{350\ \mathrm{MPa}}\right) \\ &= 275.3\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
3.5Stem depth-to-thickness ratio
λs=dw=456 mm15.9 mm=28.68\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-lambda_s}{\lambda_{s}} &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-d}{d}}{\htmlClass{sym-w}{w}} \\ &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-d}{456\ \mathrm{mm}}}{\htmlClass{sym-w}{15.9\ \mathrm{mm}}} \\ &= 28.68 \end{aligned}
3.6Compact limit, stem

AISC 360-22 Table B4.1b case 14, stems of tees

λp=0.84⋅EFy=0.84⋅200000 MPa350 MPa=20.08\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-lambda_p}{\lambda_{p}} &= 0.84 \cdot \sqrt{\frac{\htmlClass{sym-E}{E}}{\htmlClass{sym-F_y}{F_{y}}}} \\ &= 0.84 \cdot \sqrt{\frac{\htmlClass{sym-E}{200000\ \mathrm{MPa}}}{\htmlClass{sym-F_y}{350\ \mathrm{MPa}}}} \\ &= 20.08 \end{aligned}
3.7Noncompact limit, stem

AISC 360-22 Table B4.1b case 14, stems of tees

λr=1.52⋅EFy=1.52⋅200000 MPa350 MPa=36.33\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-lambda_r}{\lambda_{r}} &= 1.52 \cdot \sqrt{\frac{\htmlClass{sym-E}{E}}{\htmlClass{sym-F_y}{F_{y}}}} \\ &= 1.52 \cdot \sqrt{\frac{\htmlClass{sym-E}{200000\ \mathrm{MPa}}}{\htmlClass{sym-F_y}{350\ \mathrm{MPa}}}} \\ &= 36.33 \end{aligned}

λs>λp⇒28.68>20.08\lambda_{s} > \lambda_{p} \quad \Rightarrow \quad 28.68 > 20.08

λs≤λr⇒28.68≤36.33\lambda_{s} \leq \lambda_{r} \quad \Rightarrow \quad 28.68 \leq 36.33

3.8Stem local buckling stress

AISC 360-22 F9-18

Fcr=(1.43−0.515⋅λs⋅FyE)⋅Fy=(1.43−0.515⋅28.68⋅350 MPa200000 MPa)⋅350 MPa=284.2 MPa\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-F_cr}{F_{\mathrm{cr}}} &= \left(1.43 - 0.515 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-lambda_s}{\lambda_{s}} \cdot \sqrt{\frac{\htmlClass{sym-F_y}{F_{y}}}{\htmlClass{sym-E}{E}}}\right) \cdot \htmlClass{sym-F_y}{F_{y}} \\ &= \left(1.43 - 0.515 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-lambda_s}{28.68} \cdot \sqrt{\frac{\htmlClass{sym-F_y}{350\ \mathrm{MPa}}}{\htmlClass{sym-E}{200000\ \mathrm{MPa}}}}\right) \cdot \htmlClass{sym-F_y}{350\ \mathrm{MPa}} \\ &= 284.2\ \mathrm{MPa} \end{aligned}
3.9Stem local buckling resistance

AISC 360-22 F9-16

Mrx3=ϕ⋅Sxc⋅Fcr=0.9⋅874000 mm3⋅284.2 MPa=223.6 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_rx3}{M_{\mathrm{rx}3}} &= \htmlClass{sym-phi}{\phi} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-S_xc}{S_{\mathrm{xc}}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-F_cr}{F_{\mathrm{cr}}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-phi}{0.9} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-S_xc}{874000\ \mathrm{mm}^{3}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-F_cr}{284.2\ \mathrm{MPa}} \\ &= 223.6\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
3.10S16 Class 3 limit, stem (Table 2)

S16 Table 2, stems of T-sections with a part in tension, Class 3 limit

λc3=340Fy1 MPa=340350 MPa1 MPa=18.17\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-lambda_c3}{\lambda_{c3}} &= \frac{340}{\sqrt{\frac{\htmlClass{sym-F_y}{F_{y}}}{1\ \mathrm{MPa}}}} \\ &= \frac{340}{\sqrt{\frac{\htmlClass{sym-F_y}{350\ \mathrm{MPa}}}{1\ \mathrm{MPa}}}} \\ &= 18.17 \end{aligned}
3.11Moment resistance

AISC 360-22 F9, the lowest of the limit states; a stem past lambda_c3 is Class 4 by S16 Table 2 and Cl. 13.5 has no tee rule for it, so this is the rational method of Cl. 13.6.1 e)

Mrx=min⁡(Mrx1,Mrx2,Mrx3)=min⁡(275.3 kN⋅m,275.3 kN⋅m,223.6 kN⋅m)=223.6 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_rx}{M_{\mathrm{rx}}} &= \min\left(\htmlClass{sym-M_rx1}{M_{\mathrm{rx}1}}, \htmlClass{sym-M_rx2}{M_{\mathrm{rx}2}}, \htmlClass{sym-M_rx3}{M_{\mathrm{rx}3}}\right) \\ &= \min\left(\htmlClass{sym-M_rx1}{275.3\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}, \htmlClass{sym-M_rx2}{275.3\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}, \htmlClass{sym-M_rx3}{223.6\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}\right) \\ &= 223.6\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
4.1Tension and bending interaction

S16 Cl. 13.9.1

Ia=TfTr+MfxMrx=130 kN4504 kN+3.5 kN⋅m223.6 kN⋅m=0.04451\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-I_a}{I_{a}} &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-T_f}{T_{f}}}{\htmlClass{sym-T_r}{T_{r}}} + \frac{\htmlClass{sym-M_fx}{M_{\mathrm{fx}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-M_rx}{M_{\mathrm{rx}}}} \\ &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-T_f}{130\ \mathrm{kN}}}{\htmlClass{sym-T_r}{4504\ \mathrm{kN}}} + \frac{\htmlClass{sym-M_fx}{3.5\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-M_rx}{223.6\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}} \\ &= 0.04451 \end{aligned}
4.2Bending less tension interaction

S16 Cl. 13.9.3 b), S at the stem tip

Ib=MfxMrx−Tf⋅SxcMrx⋅A0=3.5 kN⋅m223.6 kN⋅m−130 kN⋅874000 mm3223.6 kN⋅m⋅14300 mm2=−0.01988\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-I_b}{I_{b}} &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-M_fx}{M_{\mathrm{fx}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-M_rx}{M_{\mathrm{rx}}}} - \frac{\htmlClass{sym-T_f}{T_{f}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-S_xc}{S_{\mathrm{xc}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-M_rx}{M_{\mathrm{rx}}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-A_0}{A_{0}}} \\ &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-M_fx}{3.5\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-M_rx}{223.6\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}} - \frac{\htmlClass{sym-T_f}{130\ \mathrm{kN}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-S_xc}{874000\ \mathrm{mm}^{3}}}{\htmlClass{sym-M_rx}{223.6\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-A_0}{14300\ \mathrm{mm}^{2}}} \\ &= -0.01988 \end{aligned}

Report

Sheet 1 and the first sheet of the working of the PDF report, at the declared values with a sample title block. Pro.

Show the two sheets
Sheet 1 of the WT in tension report: title block, verdict, checks and figures
Sheet 1: title block, verdict, checks, figures · full size
The first sheet of the working in the WT in tension report: each step with its clause
The working: each step with its clause · full size

Questions

Why must M_fx put the stem in compression?

The moment is taken that way only: the usual WT brace is connected by its flange, and the eccentricity then bends the stem tip into compression.

Which section modulus does the second interaction take?

The stem tip's, where the moment's compression is and the tension relieves it.

Does T_r cover the connection?

No. T_r here is gross-section yield only; the connection's block shear and net-section fracture (S16-19 Cl. 13.2 a) ii) and iii)) must be checked separately.

Revision history

After an independent checker's review: the Class 4 tee stem is now stated (S16 Table 2 limit 340 over root F_y) with the moment resistance from AISC F9 named as a substitution, service-load yielding (Cl. 13.5 a) and the truss chord L/r of 240 limit are listed as not checked, and the figure dimensions the stem
ValueWasNowUnit
lambda_c318.1738