LoadsSeismic loads, rectangular tank

Seismic design forces and overturning moments for a rectangular liquid-containing tank. Calculate seismic design forces for rectangular liquid-containing tanks per ACI 350.3-20. The calculator separates the liquid mass into impulsive and convective components, determines corresponding seismic coefficients from the NBCC 2020 spectral values of the site, and computes wall pressures by height, base shear, overturning moment, the sloshing wave height and the freeboard check. Input tank geometry, liquid properties, and the site's Sa(T) for a complete load determination.

CA$4.00 for this report, or Pro

PASS Governing: Sloshing freeboard adequate, D/C 0.98, ACI 350.3-20 7.1, the freeboard route of R7.1 a)2 of 2 checks below pass

L = 18 m twall = 650 mm hfluid = 9.15 m hwall = 10.35 m Direction of shaking
The tank in section, with the geometry the inputs name.
hfreeboard = 1.2 m qhy = 89.8 kPa py = 54.2 kPa piy = 40.7 kPa pvy = 28.7 kPa pcy = 2.7 kPa pwy = 5.2 kPa
ACI 350.3-20 R5.3.1 wall pressures and the Eq 5.3.2 combination (heavy line), each drawn straight between its traced endpoints.

Given

Jump to results

Type any value, everything below recomputes. Hover or tap a symbol to trace it.

Tank geometry
changed from the declared value LL m\mathrm{m}1-100
changed from the declared value hwallh_{\mathrm{wall}} m\mathrm{m}1-40
changed from the declared value hfluidh_{\mathrm{fluid}} m\mathrm{m}0.5-40
changed from the declared value twallt_{\mathrm{wall}} mm\mathrm{mm}100-2,000
changed from the declared value trooft_{\mathrm{roof}} mm\mathrm{mm}0-2,000
changed from the declared value tbottomt_{\mathrm{bottom}} mm\mathrm{mm}0-2,000
changed from the declared value
Materials
changed from the declared value γfluid\gamma_{\mathrm{fluid}} kN/m3\mathrm{kN/m³}1-30
changed from the declared value γconc\gamma_{\mathrm{conc}} kN/m3\mathrm{kN/m³}15-30
changed from the declared value gg m⋅s−2\mathrm{m} \cdot \mathrm{s}^{-2}9-10
Site hazard, NBCC 2020
changed from the declared value II 1-1.5
changed from the declared value Sa,02S_{a,02} 0.0001-4
changed from the declared value Sa,05S_{a,05} 0.0001-4
changed from the declared value Sa,1S_{a,1} 0.0001-4
changed from the declared value Sa,2S_{a,2} 0.0001-4
changed from the declared value Sa,5S_{a,5} 0.0001-4
changed from the declared value Sa,10S_{a,10} 0.0001-4
Response
changed from the declared value RwiR_{\mathrm{wi}} 1-3.25
changed from the declared value RwcR_{\mathrm{wc}} 1-1
changed from the declared value bb 0.6666666667-1
Other loads
changed from the declared value hegh_{\mathrm{eg}} m\mathrm{m}0-40
changed from the declared value PegP_{\mathrm{eg}} kN\mathrm{kN}0-10,000
changed from the declared value WrW_{r} kN\mathrm{kN}0-10,000
changed from the declared value CLFC_{\mathrm{LF}} 1.4-3.2

Title block

Optional. Printed in the title block of the PDF.

Checks

All 2 checks pass. Largest D/C 0.98, Sloshing freeboard adequate.

Show all 2 checks

! marks a check that passes with D/C at or above 0.95: close to its limit. The band is a site convention, not a code limit.

Check D/C Utilisation Result
Freeboard adequateinput validity, no code clause: the fluid surface is below the wall tophfreeboard≥0 mm⇒1200 mm≥0 mm\htmlClass{sym-h_freeboard}{h_{\mathrm{freeboard}}} \geq 0\ \mathrm{mm} \quad \Rightarrow \quad \htmlClass{sym-h_freeboard}{1200\ \mathrm{mm}} \geq 0\ \mathrm{mm} 0.00 PASS
Sloshing freeboard adequateACI 350.3-20 7.1, the freeboard route of R7.1 a)hfreeboard≥dmax⇒1200 mm≥1181 mm\htmlClass{sym-h_freeboard}{h_{\mathrm{freeboard}}} \geq \htmlClass{sym-d_max}{d_{\mathrm{max}}} \quad \Rightarrow \quad \htmlClass{sym-h_freeboard}{1200\ \mathrm{mm}} \geq \htmlClass{sym-d_max}{1181\ \mathrm{mm}} 0.98 PASS

Results

Base forces

Quantity Description Value Unit
V\htmlClass{sym-V}{V} Total design base shear, per 1 m width 545.1 kN\mathrm{kN}
Vt\htmlClass{sym-V_t}{V_{t}} Fluid design shear at the top of the foundation, per 1 m width 438 kN\mathrm{kN}
Ms\htmlClass{sym-M_s}{M_{s}} Bending moment just above the base of the wall, EBP (M_b), per 1 m width 2112 kN⋅m\mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}
M′s\htmlClass{sym-M_s_prime}{{M'}_{s}} Overturning moment at the base including base pressure, IBP (M_o), per 1 m width 3724 kN⋅m\mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}

Sloshing

Quantity Description Value Unit
Tc\htmlClass{sym-T_c}{T_{c}} Convective (sloshing) period 4.985 s\mathrm{s}
hfreeboard\htmlClass{sym-h_freeboard}{h_{\mathrm{freeboard}}} Freeboard above the fluid surface 1200governs mm\mathrm{mm}
dmax\htmlClass{sym-d_max}{d_{\mathrm{max}}} Sloshing wave height 1181 mm\mathrm{mm}
proof\htmlClass{sym-p_roof}{p_{\mathrm{roof}}} Roof uplift pressure from the wave 0 kPa\mathrm{kPa}

Wall pressures in kPa at height y above the base, per metre of wall width: q_hy, p_iy, p_cy, p_wy, p_vy and p_y, which is Eq 5.3.2 at each height. Leading is q_hy + p_y and trailing is q_hy - p_y, the two wall cases of R5.3.1.

y, mHydrostaticImpulsiveConvectiveWallVerticalCombinedLeadingTrailing
0.089.840.72.75.228.754.2144.035.5
0.980.837.23.35.225.949.8130.631.0
1.871.833.83.85.223.045.4117.226.4
2.762.830.34.45.220.141.0103.821.8
3.753.926.85.05.217.236.690.517.2
4.644.923.35.55.214.432.477.212.5
5.535.919.86.15.211.528.264.17.8
6.426.916.36.75.28.624.151.02.8
7.318.012.87.35.25.720.238.2-2.3
8.29.09.37.85.22.916.725.7-7.7
9.20.05.88.45.20.013.813.8-13.8
10.30.00.00.05.20.05.25.2-5.2
Also worth checking
  • The strength of the walls, base slab and roof against the forces and pressures, which this sheet only produces
  • The dynamic earth pressure on a buried wall, which R5.3.2 leaves to the geotechnical engineer
  • The confined sloshing mass that R7.1 adds to the impulsive mass, and corner sloshing from both directions
  • Sliding, overturning and bearing of the tank on its foundation
  • I, R_i and R_c are inputs from ACI 350.3-20 Tables 4.1.1a and 4.1.1b; NBC's I_E, R_d and R_o are not applied, and any freeboard rule of the owner
  • Shear transfer at the wall-to-floor, wall-to-wall and wall-to-roof joints, Cl. 3.3.2 and 5.2.1
  • The in-plane forces on the walls parallel to the shaking, Cl. 5.3.1
  • The 80 percent floor of Cl. 9.5 on the Cl. 9.4 values, and the deterministic cap of Cl. 4.2.1
  • Other liquid levels, including the tank or a cell empty, R1.1
  • P_eg and h_eg, which are inputs to be taken from Chapter 8 or the geotechnical report

Derivation

heg≤hwall⇒0 m≤10.35 mh_{\mathrm{eg}} \leq h_{\mathrm{wall}} \quad \Rightarrow \quad 0\ \mathrm{m} \leq 10.35\ \mathrm{m}

1.1Design strip width
B=1000 mm\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-B}{B} &= 1000\ \mathrm{mm} \end{aligned}
1.2Fluid weight
Wfluid=L⋅B⋅hfluid⋅γfluid=18 m⋅1000 mm⋅9.15 m⋅9.81 kN/m3=1616 kN\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-W_fluid}{W_{\mathrm{fluid}}} &= \htmlClass{sym-L}{L} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-B}{B} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-gamma_fluid}{\gamma_{\mathrm{fluid}}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-B}{1000\ \mathrm{mm}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-gamma_fluid}{9.81\ \mathrm{kN/m³}} \\ &= 1616\ \mathrm{kN} \end{aligned}
1.3Freeboard
hfreeboard=hwall−hfluid=10.35 m−9.15 m=1200 mm\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-h_freeboard}{h_{\mathrm{freeboard}}} &= \htmlClass{sym-h_wall}{h_{\mathrm{wall}}} - \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-h_wall}{10.35\ \mathrm{m}} - \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}} \\ &= 1200\ \mathrm{mm} \end{aligned}
1.4Impulsive weight

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 9.2.1a

Wi=tanh⁡(0.866⋅Lhfluid)0.866⋅Lhfluid⋅Wfluid=tanh⁡(0.866⋅18 m9.15 m)0.866⋅18 m9.15 m⋅1616 kN=887.6 kN\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-W_i}{W_{i}} &= \frac{\tanh\left(0.866 \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}\right)}{0.866 \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-W_fluid}{W_{\mathrm{fluid}}} \\ &= \frac{\tanh\left(0.866 \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}\right)}{0.866 \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-W_fluid}{1616\ \mathrm{kN}} \\ &= 887.6\ \mathrm{kN} \end{aligned}
1.5Convective weight

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 9.2.1b

Wc=0.264⋅Lhfluid⋅tanh⁡(3.16⋅hfluidL)⋅Wfluid=0.264⋅18 m9.15 m⋅tanh⁡(3.16⋅9.15 m18 m)⋅1616 kN=774.2 kN\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-W_c}{W_{c}} &= 0.264 \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}} \cdot \tanh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}\right) \cdot \htmlClass{sym-W_fluid}{W_{\mathrm{fluid}}} \\ &= 0.264 \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}} \cdot \tanh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}\right) \cdot \htmlClass{sym-W_fluid}{1616\ \mathrm{kN}} \\ &= 774.2\ \mathrm{kN} \end{aligned}
1.6Wall weight
Wwalls=γconc⋅2⋅twall⋅hwall⋅B=23.56 kN/m3⋅2⋅650 mm⋅10.35 m⋅1000 mm=317 kN\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-W_walls}{W_{\mathrm{walls}}} &= \htmlClass{sym-gamma_conc}{\gamma_{\mathrm{conc}}} \cdot 2 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-t_wall}{t_{\mathrm{wall}}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_wall}{h_{\mathrm{wall}}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-B}{B} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-gamma_conc}{23.56\ \mathrm{kN/m³}} \cdot 2 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-t_wall}{650\ \mathrm{mm}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_wall}{10.35\ \mathrm{m}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-B}{1000\ \mathrm{mm}} \\ &= 317\ \mathrm{kN} \end{aligned}
1.7Effective mass coefficient

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 9.6.1

ϵ=min⁡(0.0151⋅(Lhfluid)2−0.1908⋅Lhfluid+1.021,1)=min⁡(0.0151⋅(18 m9.15 m)2−0.1908⋅18 m9.15 m+1.021,1)=0.7041\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-epsilon}{\epsilon} &= \min\left(0.0151 \cdot \left(\frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}\right)^{2} - 0.1908 \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}} + 1.021, 1\right) \\ &= \min\left(0.0151 \cdot \left(\frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}\right)^{2} - 0.1908 \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}} + 1.021, 1\right) \\ &= 0.7041 \end{aligned}
2.1Convective period

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 9.2.4d, 9.2.4e, 9.2.4f

Tc=2⋅π⋅L3.16⋅g⋅tanh⁡(3.16⋅hfluidL)=2⋅π⋅18 m3.16⋅9.807 m⋅s−2⋅tanh⁡(3.16⋅9.15 m18 m)=4.985 s\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-T_c}{T_{c}} &= 2 \cdot \pi \cdot \sqrt{\frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-g}{g} \cdot \tanh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}\right)}} \\ &= 2 \cdot \pi \cdot \sqrt{\frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-g}{9.807\ \mathrm{m} \cdot \mathrm{s}^{-2}} \cdot \tanh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}\right)}} \\ &= 4.985\ \mathrm{s} \end{aligned}
2.2Impulsive spectral acceleration

NBC 2020 Table 4.1.8.4.-C and ACI 350.3-20 9.5, S_aM

SaM=max⁡(Sa,02,Sa,05,0.9⋅max⁡(Sa,1,Sa,2,Sa,5,Sa,10))=max⁡(1.08,0.866,0.9⋅max⁡(0.503,0.306,0.0871,0.0369))=1.08\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-S_aM}{S_{\mathrm{aM}}} &= \max\left(\htmlClass{sym-S_a_02}{S_{a,02}}, \htmlClass{sym-S_a_05}{S_{a,05}}, 0.9 \cdot \max\left(\htmlClass{sym-S_a_1}{S_{a,1}}, \htmlClass{sym-S_a_2}{S_{a,2}}, \htmlClass{sym-S_a_5}{S_{a,5}}, \htmlClass{sym-S_a_10}{S_{a,10}}\right)\right) \\ &= \max\left(\htmlClass{sym-S_a_02}{1.08}, \htmlClass{sym-S_a_05}{0.866}, 0.9 \cdot \max\left(\htmlClass{sym-S_a_1}{0.503}, \htmlClass{sym-S_a_2}{0.306}, \htmlClass{sym-S_a_5}{0.0871}, \htmlClass{sym-S_a_10}{0.0369}\right)\right) \\ &= 1.08 \end{aligned}

Tc>2 s⇒4.985 s>2 sT_{c} > 2\ \mathrm{s} \quad \Rightarrow \quad 4.985\ \mathrm{s} > 2\ \mathrm{s}

Tc≤5 s⇒4.985 s≤5 sT_{c} \leq 5\ \mathrm{s} \quad \Rightarrow \quad 4.985\ \mathrm{s} \leq 5\ \mathrm{s}

2.3Spectral acceleration at T_c

NBC 2020 Sentence 4.1.8.4.(6) and Note A-4.1.8.4.(6)

ST,c=Sa,2⋅exp⁡(ln⁡(Sa,5Sa,2)⋅ln⁡(Tc2 s)0.9163)=0.306⋅exp⁡(ln⁡(0.08710.306)⋅ln⁡(4.985 s2 s)0.9163)=0.08745\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-S_T_c}{S_{T,c}} &= \htmlClass{sym-S_a_2}{S_{a,2}} \cdot \exp\left(\frac{\ln\left(\frac{\htmlClass{sym-S_a_5}{S_{a,5}}}{\htmlClass{sym-S_a_2}{S_{a,2}}}\right) \cdot \ln\left(\frac{\htmlClass{sym-T_c}{T_{c}}}{2\ \mathrm{s}}\right)}{0.9163}\right) \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-S_a_2}{0.306} \cdot \exp\left(\frac{\ln\left(\frac{\htmlClass{sym-S_a_5}{0.0871}}{\htmlClass{sym-S_a_2}{0.306}}\right) \cdot \ln\left(\frac{\htmlClass{sym-T_c}{4.985\ \mathrm{s}}}{2\ \mathrm{s}}\right)}{0.9163}\right) \\ &= 0.08745 \end{aligned}
2.4Convective spectral acceleration

ACI 350.3-20 9.5, 150 percent of the 5 percent damped response at T_c

ScM=1.5⋅ST,c=1.5⋅0.08745=0.1312\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-S_cM}{S_{\mathrm{cM}}} &= 1.5 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-S_T_c}{S_{T,c}} \\ &= 1.5 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-S_T_c}{0.08745} \\ &= 0.1312 \end{aligned}
2.5Impulsive coefficient

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 9.5a

Ci=2⋅SaM3=2⋅1.083=0.72\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-C_i}{C_{i}} &= \frac{2 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-S_aM}{S_{\mathrm{aM}}}}{3} \\ &= \frac{2 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-S_aM}{1.08}}{3} \\ &= 0.72 \end{aligned}
2.6Vertical coefficient

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 9.4.3b, rectangular tank

Ct=Ci=0.72\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-C_t}{C_{t}} &= \htmlClass{sym-C_i}{C_{i}} \\ &= 0.72 \end{aligned}
2.7Convective coefficient

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 9.5b

Cc=2⋅ScM3=2⋅0.13123=0.08745\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-C_c}{C_{c}} &= \frac{2 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-S_cM}{S_{\mathrm{cM}}}}{3} \\ &= \frac{2 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-S_cM}{0.1312}}{3} \\ &= 0.08745 \end{aligned}

Lhfluid≥0.75⇒18 m9.15 m≥0.75\frac{L}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}} \geq 0.75 \quad \Rightarrow \quad \frac{18\ \mathrm{m}}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}} \geq 0.75

3.1Impulsive height, with base pressure

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 9.2.3b

h′i=(0.866⋅Lhfluid2⋅tanh⁡(0.866⋅Lhfluid)−18)⋅hfluid=(0.866⋅18 m9.15 m2⋅tanh⁡(0.866⋅18 m9.15 m)−18)⋅9.15 m=7184 mm\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-h_i_prime}{{h'}_{i}} &= \left(\frac{\frac{0.866 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}}{2 \cdot \tanh\left(\frac{0.866 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}\right)} - \frac{1}{8}\right) \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}} \\ &= \left(\frac{\frac{0.866 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}}{2 \cdot \tanh\left(\frac{0.866 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}\right)} - \frac{1}{8}\right) \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}} \\ &= 7184\ \mathrm{mm} \end{aligned}
3.2Convective height, with base pressure

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 9.2.3c

h′c=(1−cosh⁡(3.16⋅hfluidL)−2.013.16⋅hfluidL⋅sinh⁡(3.16⋅hfluidL))⋅hfluid=(1−cosh⁡(3.16⋅9.15 m18 m)−2.013.16⋅9.15 m18 m⋅sinh⁡(3.16⋅9.15 m18 m))⋅9.15 m=7763 mm\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-h_c_prime}{{h'}_{c}} &= \left(1 - \frac{\cosh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}\right) - 2.01}{\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}} \cdot \sinh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}\right)}\right) \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}} \\ &= \left(1 - \frac{\cosh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}\right) - 2.01}{\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}} \cdot \sinh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}\right)}\right) \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}} \\ &= 7763\ \mathrm{mm} \end{aligned}
3.3Wall centre of gravity

ACI 350.3-20 1.2, h_w, centre of gravity of the wall

Hw=hwall2=10.35 m2=5175 mm\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-H_w}{H_{w}} &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-h_wall}{h_{\mathrm{wall}}}}{2} \\ &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-h_wall}{10.35\ \mathrm{m}}}{2} \\ &= 5175\ \mathrm{mm} \end{aligned}
3.4Roof centre of gravity

ACI 350.3-20 1.2, h_r, centre of gravity of the roof

hroof=hwall+troof2=10.35 m+0 mm2=10350 mm\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-h_roof}{h_{\mathrm{roof}}} &= \htmlClass{sym-h_wall}{h_{\mathrm{wall}}} + \frac{\htmlClass{sym-t_roof}{t_{\mathrm{roof}}}}{2} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-h_wall}{10.35\ \mathrm{m}} + \frac{\htmlClass{sym-t_roof}{0\ \mathrm{mm}}}{2} \\ &= 10350\ \mathrm{mm} \end{aligned}

Lhfluid≥1.333⇒18 m9.15 m≥1.333\frac{L}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}} \geq 1.333 \quad \Rightarrow \quad \frac{18\ \mathrm{m}}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}} \geq 1.333

3.5Impulsive height

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 9.2.2b

hi=0.375⋅hfluid=0.375⋅9.15 m=3431 mm\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-h_i}{h_{i}} &= 0.375 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}} \\ &= 0.375 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}} \\ &= 3431\ \mathrm{mm} \end{aligned}
3.6Convective height

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 9.2.2c

hc=(1−cosh⁡(3.16⋅hfluidL)−13.16⋅hfluidL⋅sinh⁡(3.16⋅hfluidL))⋅hfluid=(1−cosh⁡(3.16⋅9.15 m18 m)−13.16⋅9.15 m18 m⋅sinh⁡(3.16⋅9.15 m18 m))⋅9.15 m=5357 mm\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-h_c}{h_{c}} &= \left(1 - \frac{\cosh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}\right) - 1}{\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}} \cdot \sinh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}\right)}\right) \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}} \\ &= \left(1 - \frac{\cosh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}\right) - 1}{\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}} \cdot \sinh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}\right)}\right) \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}} \\ &= 5357\ \mathrm{mm} \end{aligned}
4.1Wall inertia force

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.1a

Pw=I⋅Ci⋅ϵ⋅WwallsRwi=1.5⋅0.72⋅0.7041⋅317 kN2.25=107.1 kN\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-P_w}{P_{w}} &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-I}{I} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-C_i}{C_{i}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-epsilon}{\epsilon} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-W_walls}{W_{\mathrm{walls}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-R_wi}{R_{\mathrm{wi}}}} \\ &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-I}{1.5} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-C_i}{0.72} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-epsilon}{0.7041} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-W_walls}{317\ \mathrm{kN}}}{\htmlClass{sym-R_wi}{2.25}} \\ &= 107.1\ \mathrm{kN} \end{aligned}
4.2Roof inertia force

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.1c

Pr=I⋅Ci⋅WrRwi=1.5⋅0.72⋅5 kN2.25=2.4 kN\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-P_r}{P_{r}} &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-I}{I} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-C_i}{C_{i}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-W_r}{W_{r}}}{\htmlClass{sym-R_wi}{R_{\mathrm{wi}}}} \\ &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-I}{1.5} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-C_i}{0.72} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-W_r}{5\ \mathrm{kN}}}{\htmlClass{sym-R_wi}{2.25}} \\ &= 2.4\ \mathrm{kN} \end{aligned}
4.3Impulsive force

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.1d

Pi=I⋅Ci⋅WiRwi=1.5⋅0.72⋅887.6 kN2.25=426 kN\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-P_i}{P_{i}} &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-I}{I} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-C_i}{C_{i}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-W_i}{W_{i}}}{\htmlClass{sym-R_wi}{R_{\mathrm{wi}}}} \\ &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-I}{1.5} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-C_i}{0.72} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-W_i}{887.6\ \mathrm{kN}}}{\htmlClass{sym-R_wi}{2.25}} \\ &= 426\ \mathrm{kN} \end{aligned}
4.4Convective force

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.1e

Pc=Cc⋅I⋅WcRwc=0.08745⋅1.5⋅774.2 kN1=101.6 kN\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-P_c}{P_{c}} &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-C_c}{C_{c}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-I}{I} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-W_c}{W_{c}}}{\htmlClass{sym-R_wc}{R_{\mathrm{wc}}}} \\ &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-C_c}{0.08745} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-I}{1.5} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-W_c}{774.2\ \mathrm{kN}}}{\htmlClass{sym-R_wc}{1}} \\ &= 101.6\ \mathrm{kN} \end{aligned}
4.5Fluid base shear
Vt=Pc2+Pi2=(101.6 kN)2+(426 kN)2=438 kN\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-V_t}{V_{t}} &= \sqrt{\htmlClass{sym-P_c}{P_{c}}^{2} + \htmlClass{sym-P_i}{P_{i}}^{2}} \\ &= \sqrt{\left(\htmlClass{sym-P_c}{101.6\ \mathrm{kN}}\right)^{2} + \left(\htmlClass{sym-P_i}{426\ \mathrm{kN}}\right)^{2}} \\ &= 438\ \mathrm{kN} \end{aligned}
4.6Total base shear

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.2

V=(Pi+Pw+Pr)2+Pc2+Peg2=(426 kN+107.1 kN+2.4 kN)2+(101.6 kN)2+(0 kN)2=545.1 kN\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-V}{V} &= \sqrt{\left(\htmlClass{sym-P_i}{P_{i}} + \htmlClass{sym-P_w}{P_{w}} + \htmlClass{sym-P_r}{P_{r}}\right)^{2} + \htmlClass{sym-P_c}{P_{c}}^{2} + \htmlClass{sym-P_eg}{P_{\mathrm{eg}}}^{2}} \\ &= \sqrt{\left(\htmlClass{sym-P_i}{426\ \mathrm{kN}} + \htmlClass{sym-P_w}{107.1\ \mathrm{kN}} + \htmlClass{sym-P_r}{2.4\ \mathrm{kN}}\right)^{2} + \left(\htmlClass{sym-P_c}{101.6\ \mathrm{kN}}\right)^{2} + \left(\htmlClass{sym-P_eg}{0\ \mathrm{kN}}\right)^{2}} \\ &= 545.1\ \mathrm{kN} \end{aligned}
5.1Wall moment

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.3a

Mw=Pw⋅Hw=107.1 kN⋅5175 mm=554.4 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_w}{M_{w}} &= \htmlClass{sym-P_w}{P_{w}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-H_w}{H_{w}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-P_w}{107.1\ \mathrm{kN}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-H_w}{5175\ \mathrm{mm}} \\ &= 554.4\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
5.2Roof moment

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.3b

Mr=Pr⋅hroof=2.4 kN⋅10350 mm=24.84 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_r}{M_{r}} &= \htmlClass{sym-P_r}{P_{r}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_roof}{h_{\mathrm{roof}}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-P_r}{2.4\ \mathrm{kN}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_roof}{10350\ \mathrm{mm}} \\ &= 24.84\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
5.3Impulsive moment

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.3c

Mi=Pi⋅hi=426 kN⋅3431 mm=1462 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_i}{M_{i}} &= \htmlClass{sym-P_i}{P_{i}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_i}{h_{i}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-P_i}{426\ \mathrm{kN}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_i}{3431\ \mathrm{mm}} \\ &= 1462\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
5.4Convective moment

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.3d

Mc=Pc⋅hc=101.6 kN⋅5357 mm=544.1 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_c}{M_{c}} &= \htmlClass{sym-P_c}{P_{c}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_c}{h_{c}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-P_c}{101.6\ \mathrm{kN}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_c}{5357\ \mathrm{mm}} \\ &= 544.1\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
5.5Earth pressure moment

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.3e

Meg=Peg⋅heg=0 kN⋅0 m=0 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_eg}{M_{\mathrm{eg}}} &= \htmlClass{sym-P_eg}{P_{\mathrm{eg}}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_eg}{h_{\mathrm{eg}}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-P_eg}{0\ \mathrm{kN}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_eg}{0\ \mathrm{m}} \\ &= 0\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
5.6Base moment

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.3f

Ms=(Mi+Mw+Mr)2+Mc2+Meg2=(1462 kN⋅m+554.4 kN⋅m+24.84 kN⋅m)2+(544.1 kN⋅m)2+(0 kN⋅m)2=2112 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_s}{M_{s}} &= \sqrt{\left(\htmlClass{sym-M_i}{M_{i}} + \htmlClass{sym-M_w}{M_{w}} + \htmlClass{sym-M_r}{M_{r}}\right)^{2} + \htmlClass{sym-M_c}{M_{c}}^{2} + \htmlClass{sym-M_eg}{M_{\mathrm{eg}}}^{2}} \\ &= \sqrt{\left(\htmlClass{sym-M_i}{1462\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}} + \htmlClass{sym-M_w}{554.4\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}} + \htmlClass{sym-M_r}{24.84\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}\right)^{2} + \left(\htmlClass{sym-M_c}{544.1\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}\right)^{2} + \left(\htmlClass{sym-M_eg}{0\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}\right)^{2}} \\ &= 2112\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
5.7Impulsive moment, with base pressure

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.3g

M′i=Pi⋅h′i=426 kN⋅7184 mm=3061 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_i_prime}{{M'}_{i}} &= \htmlClass{sym-P_i}{P_{i}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_i_prime}{{h'}_{i}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-P_i}{426\ \mathrm{kN}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_i_prime}{7184\ \mathrm{mm}} \\ &= 3061\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
5.8Convective moment, with base pressure

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.3h

M′c=Pc⋅h′c=101.6 kN⋅7763 mm=788.3 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_c_prime}{{M'}_{c}} &= \htmlClass{sym-P_c}{P_{c}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_c_prime}{{h'}_{c}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-P_c}{101.6\ \mathrm{kN}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_c_prime}{7763\ \mathrm{mm}} \\ &= 788.3\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
5.9Overturning moment

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.3i

M′s=(M′i+Mw+Mr)2+M′c2+Meg2=(3061 kN⋅m+554.4 kN⋅m+24.84 kN⋅m)2+(788.3 kN⋅m)2+(0 kN⋅m)2=3724 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-M_s_prime}{{M'}_{s}} &= \sqrt{\left(\htmlClass{sym-M_i_prime}{{M'}_{i}} + \htmlClass{sym-M_w}{M_{w}} + \htmlClass{sym-M_r}{M_{r}}\right)^{2} + \htmlClass{sym-M_c_prime}{{M'}_{c}}^{2} + \htmlClass{sym-M_eg}{M_{\mathrm{eg}}}^{2}} \\ &= \sqrt{\left(\htmlClass{sym-M_i_prime}{3061\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}} + \htmlClass{sym-M_w}{554.4\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}} + \htmlClass{sym-M_r}{24.84\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}\right)^{2} + \left(\htmlClass{sym-M_c_prime}{788.3\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}\right)^{2} + \left(\htmlClass{sym-M_eg}{0\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m}}\right)^{2}} \\ &= 3724\ \mathrm{kN} \cdot \mathrm{m} \end{aligned}
6.1Sloshing height

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 7.1a

dmax=L2⋅Cc⋅I=18 m2⋅0.08745⋅1.5=1181 mm\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-d_max}{d_{\mathrm{max}}} &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}{2} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-C_c}{C_{c}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-I}{I} \\ &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}{2} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-C_c}{0.08745} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-I}{1.5} \\ &= 1181\ \mathrm{mm} \end{aligned}
6.2Sloshing frequency ratio

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 7.1b, 9.2.4f

χ=g⋅Tc22⋅π2⋅Cc⋅L=9.807 m⋅s−2⋅(4.985 s)22⋅π2⋅0.08745⋅18 m=7.844\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-chi}{\chi} &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-g}{g} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-T_c}{T_{c}}^{2}}{2 \cdot \pi^{2} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-C_c}{C_{c}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-L}{L}} \\ &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-g}{9.807\ \mathrm{m} \cdot \mathrm{s}^{-2}} \cdot \left(\htmlClass{sym-T_c}{4.985\ \mathrm{s}}\right)^{2}}{2 \cdot \pi^{2} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-C_c}{0.08745} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}} \\ &= 7.844 \end{aligned}

χ>1⇒7.844>1\chi > 1 \quad \Rightarrow \quad 7.844 > 1

6.3Sloshing height, refined

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 7.1b, in lieu of 7.1a; it can exceed d_max at small L / h_L, so the check uses 7.1a

dmax,refined=0.264⋅L⋅I(χ−1)⋅tanh⁡(3.16⋅hfluidL)=0.264⋅18 m⋅1.5(7.844−1)⋅tanh⁡(3.16⋅9.15 m18 m)=1129 mm\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-d_max_refined}{d_{\mathrm{max},\mathrm{refined}}} &= \frac{0.264 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-L}{L} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-I}{I}}{\left(\htmlClass{sym-chi}{\chi} - 1\right) \cdot \tanh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{L}}\right)} \\ &= \frac{0.264 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-I}{1.5}}{\left(\htmlClass{sym-chi}{7.844} - 1\right) \cdot \tanh\left(\frac{3.16 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}}{\htmlClass{sym-L}{18\ \mathrm{m}}}\right)} \\ &= 1129\ \mathrm{mm} \end{aligned}
6.4Freeboard to the roof

ACI 350.3-20 R7.1, h_o from the still surface to the roof soffit

ho=max⁡(hfreeboard,0 mm)=max⁡(1200 mm,0 mm)=1200 mm\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-h_o}{h_{o}} &= \max\left(\htmlClass{sym-h_freeboard}{h_{\mathrm{freeboard}}}, 0\ \mathrm{mm}\right) \\ &= \max\left(\htmlClass{sym-h_freeboard}{1200\ \mathrm{mm}}, 0\ \mathrm{mm}\right) \\ &= 1200\ \mathrm{mm} \end{aligned}

roof=“Covered”\mathrm{roof} = \text{``Covered''} and dmaxI≤ho⇒1181 mm1.5≤1200 mm\frac{d_{\mathrm{max}}}{I} \leq h_{o} \quad \Rightarrow \quad \frac{1181\ \mathrm{mm}}{1.5} \leq 1200\ \mathrm{mm}

6.5Roof uplift pressure
proof=0 kPa(No uplift: open tank or the wave short of the roof | ACI 350.3-20 R7.1)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-p_roof}{p_{\mathrm{roof}}} &= 0\ \mathrm{kPa} \quad \left(\text{No uplift: open tank or the wave short of the roof | ACI 350.3-20 R7.1}\right) \end{aligned}
6.6Roof length in uplift
Li=0 mm(No uplift strip | ACI 350.3-20 R7.1)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-L_i}{L_{i}} &= 0\ \mathrm{mm} \quad \left(\text{No uplift strip | ACI 350.3-20 R7.1}\right) \end{aligned}
7.1Hydrostatic pressure at the base

ACI 350.3-20 R5.3.1, q_hy = gamma_L (H_L - y) at y = 0

qhy,base=γfluid⋅hfluid=9.81 kN/m3⋅9.15 m=89.76 kPa\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-q_hy_base}{q_{\mathrm{hy},\mathrm{base}}} &= \htmlClass{sym-gamma_fluid}{\gamma_{\mathrm{fluid}}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-gamma_fluid}{9.81\ \mathrm{kN/m³}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}} \\ &= 89.76\ \mathrm{kPa} \end{aligned}
7.2Vertical acceleration coefficient

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.4.2b, S_DS taken as C_i

uv=max⁡(Ct⋅I⋅bRwi,0.2⋅Ci)=max⁡(0.72⋅1.5⋅0.66672.25,0.2⋅0.72)=0.32\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-u_v}{u_{v}} &= \max\left(\frac{\htmlClass{sym-C_t}{C_{t}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-I}{I} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-b}{b}}{\htmlClass{sym-R_wi}{R_{\mathrm{wi}}}}, 0.2 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-C_i}{C_{i}}\right) \\ &= \max\left(\frac{\htmlClass{sym-C_t}{0.72} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-I}{1.5} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-b}{0.6667}}{\htmlClass{sym-R_wi}{2.25}}, 0.2 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-C_i}{0.72}\right) \\ &= 0.32 \end{aligned}
7.3Hydrodynamic vertical pressure at the base

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 4.1.4.2a, zero at the fluid surface

pvy,base=uv⋅qhy,base=0.32⋅89.76 kPa=28.72 kPa\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-p_vy_base}{p_{\mathrm{vy},\mathrm{base}}} &= \htmlClass{sym-u_v}{u_{v}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-q_hy_base}{q_{\mathrm{hy},\mathrm{base}}} \\ &= \htmlClass{sym-u_v}{0.32} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-q_hy_base}{89.76\ \mathrm{kPa}} \\ &= 28.72\ \mathrm{kPa} \end{aligned}
7.4Wall inertia pressure

ACI 350.3-20 R5.3.1, uniform over h_wall

pwy=Ci⋅I⋅ϵ⋅γconc⋅twallRwi=0.72⋅1.5⋅0.7041⋅23.56 kN/m3⋅650 mm2.25=5.176 kPa\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-p_wy}{p_{\mathrm{wy}}} &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-C_i}{C_{i}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-I}{I} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-epsilon}{\epsilon} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-gamma_conc}{\gamma_{\mathrm{conc}}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-t_wall}{t_{\mathrm{wall}}}}{\htmlClass{sym-R_wi}{R_{\mathrm{wi}}}} \\ &= \frac{\htmlClass{sym-C_i}{0.72} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-I}{1.5} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-epsilon}{0.7041} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-gamma_conc}{23.56\ \mathrm{kN/m³}} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-t_wall}{650\ \mathrm{mm}}}{\htmlClass{sym-R_wi}{2.25}} \\ &= 5.176\ \mathrm{kPa} \end{aligned}
7.5Impulsive pressure at the base

ACI 350.3-20 R5.3.1, linear, y = 0

piy,base=(4⋅hfluid−6⋅hi)⋅Pi2hfluid2⋅B=(4⋅9.15 m−6⋅3431 mm)⋅426 kN2(9.15 m)2⋅1000 mm=40.74 kPa\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-p_iy_base}{p_{\mathrm{iy},\mathrm{base}}} &= \frac{\left(4 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}} - 6 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_i}{h_{i}}\right) \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-P_i}{P_{i}}}{2}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}^{2} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-B}{B}} \\ &= \frac{\left(4 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}} - 6 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_i}{3431\ \mathrm{mm}}\right) \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-P_i}{426\ \mathrm{kN}}}{2}}{\left(\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}\right)^{2} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-B}{1000\ \mathrm{mm}}} \\ &= 40.74\ \mathrm{kPa} \end{aligned}
7.6Impulsive pressure at the fluid top

ACI 350.3-20 R5.3.1, linear, y = h_L

piy,top=(6⋅hi−2⋅hfluid)⋅Pi2hfluid2⋅B=(6⋅3431 mm−2⋅9.15 m)⋅426 kN2(9.15 m)2⋅1000 mm=5.82 kPa\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-p_iy_top}{p_{\mathrm{iy},\mathrm{top}}} &= \frac{\left(6 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_i}{h_{i}} - 2 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}\right) \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-P_i}{P_{i}}}{2}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}^{2} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-B}{B}} \\ &= \frac{\left(6 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_i}{3431\ \mathrm{mm}} - 2 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}\right) \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-P_i}{426\ \mathrm{kN}}}{2}}{\left(\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}\right)^{2} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-B}{1000\ \mathrm{mm}}} \\ &= 5.82\ \mathrm{kPa} \end{aligned}

hc<2⋅hfluid3⇒5357 mm<2⋅9.15 m3h_{c} < \frac{2 \cdot h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}{3} \quad \Rightarrow \quad 5357\ \mathrm{mm} < \frac{2 \cdot 9.15\ \mathrm{m}}{3}

7.7Convective distribution origin
ycy0=0 mm(Linear from the base | ACI 350.3-20 R5.3.1)\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-y_cy0}{y_{\mathrm{cy}0}} &= 0\ \mathrm{mm} \quad \left(\text{Linear from the base | ACI 350.3-20 R5.3.1}\right) \end{aligned}
7.8Convective pressure at the base

ACI 350.3-20 R5.3.1, y = 0

pcy,base=(4⋅hfluid−6⋅hc)⋅Pc2hfluid2⋅B=(4⋅9.15 m−6⋅5357 mm)⋅101.6 kN2(9.15 m)2⋅1000 mm=2.702 kPa\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-p_cy_base}{p_{\mathrm{cy},\mathrm{base}}} &= \frac{\left(4 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}} - 6 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_c}{h_{c}}\right) \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-P_c}{P_{c}}}{2}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}^{2} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-B}{B}} \\ &= \frac{\left(4 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}} - 6 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_c}{5357\ \mathrm{mm}}\right) \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-P_c}{101.6\ \mathrm{kN}}}{2}}{\left(\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}\right)^{2} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-B}{1000\ \mathrm{mm}}} \\ &= 2.702\ \mathrm{kPa} \end{aligned}
7.9Convective pressure at the fluid top

ACI 350.3-20 R5.3.1, y = h_L

pcy,top=(6⋅hc−2⋅hfluid)⋅Pc2hfluid2⋅B=(6⋅5357 mm−2⋅9.15 m)⋅101.6 kN2(9.15 m)2⋅1000 mm=8.397 kPa\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-p_cy_top}{p_{\mathrm{cy},\mathrm{top}}} &= \frac{\left(6 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_c}{h_{c}} - 2 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}\right) \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-P_c}{P_{c}}}{2}}{\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{h_{\mathrm{fluid}}}^{2} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-B}{B}} \\ &= \frac{\left(6 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_c}{5357\ \mathrm{mm}} - 2 \cdot \htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}\right) \cdot \frac{\htmlClass{sym-P_c}{101.6\ \mathrm{kN}}}{2}}{\left(\htmlClass{sym-h_fluid}{9.15\ \mathrm{m}}\right)^{2} \cdot \htmlClass{sym-B}{1000\ \mathrm{mm}}} \\ &= 8.397\ \mathrm{kPa} \end{aligned}
7.10Combined pressure at the base

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 5.3.2, y = 0

py,base=(piy,base+pwy)2+pcy,base2+pvy,base2=(40.74 kPa+5.176 kPa)2+(2.702 kPa)2+(28.72 kPa)2=54.23 kPa\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-p_y_base}{p_{y,\mathrm{base}}} &= \sqrt{\left(\htmlClass{sym-p_iy_base}{p_{\mathrm{iy},\mathrm{base}}} + \htmlClass{sym-p_wy}{p_{\mathrm{wy}}}\right)^{2} + \htmlClass{sym-p_cy_base}{p_{\mathrm{cy},\mathrm{base}}}^{2} + \htmlClass{sym-p_vy_base}{p_{\mathrm{vy},\mathrm{base}}}^{2}} \\ &= \sqrt{\left(\htmlClass{sym-p_iy_base}{40.74\ \mathrm{kPa}} + \htmlClass{sym-p_wy}{5.176\ \mathrm{kPa}}\right)^{2} + \left(\htmlClass{sym-p_cy_base}{2.702\ \mathrm{kPa}}\right)^{2} + \left(\htmlClass{sym-p_vy_base}{28.72\ \mathrm{kPa}}\right)^{2}} \\ &= 54.23\ \mathrm{kPa} \end{aligned}
7.11Combined pressure at the fluid top

ACI 350.3-20 Eq 5.3.2, y = h_L

py,top=(piy,top+pwy)2+pcy,top2=(5.82 kPa+5.176 kPa)2+(8.397 kPa)2=13.84 kPa\begin{aligned} \htmlClass{sym-p_y_top}{p_{y,\mathrm{top}}} &= \sqrt{\left(\htmlClass{sym-p_iy_top}{p_{\mathrm{iy},\mathrm{top}}} + \htmlClass{sym-p_wy}{p_{\mathrm{wy}}}\right)^{2} + \htmlClass{sym-p_cy_top}{p_{\mathrm{cy},\mathrm{top}}}^{2}} \\ &= \sqrt{\left(\htmlClass{sym-p_iy_top}{5.82\ \mathrm{kPa}} + \htmlClass{sym-p_wy}{5.176\ \mathrm{kPa}}\right)^{2} + \left(\htmlClass{sym-p_cy_top}{8.397\ \mathrm{kPa}}\right)^{2}} \\ &= 13.84\ \mathrm{kPa} \end{aligned}

Report

Sheet 1 and the first sheet of the working of the PDF report, at the declared values with a sample title block. Pro.

Show the two sheets
Sheet 1 of the Seismic loads, rectangular tank report: title block, verdict, checks and figures
Sheet 1: title block, verdict, checks, figures · full size
The first sheet of the working in the Seismic loads, rectangular tank report: each step with its clause
The working: each step with its clause · full size

Questions

How do the NBCC 2020 values S_a_02 to S_a_10 replace S_s, S_1, F_a and F_v, and what does the sheet assume?

ACI 350.3-20 reads the ASCE 7-16 maps, its site coefficients and a long-period corner T_L, and Canada has none of them. NBCC 2020 publishes the 5% damped Sa(T) at 2% in 50 years for the site designation itself, with the site coefficients already inside, so the sheet takes Sa at 0.2, 0.5, 1.0, 2.0, 5.0 and 10 s from the Earthquakes Canada seismic hazard tool and goes through ACI 350.3-20 Section 9.5, the route written for a site-specific spectrum, whose probabilistic spectrum in 4.2.2 is that one. S_aM is the greater of Sa(0.2) and Sa(0.5), the plateau of NBC Table 4.1.8.4.-C, and not below 90% of the largest longer-period value: the impulsive plateau, since the impulsive mode is taken as rigid (Appendix A step 8) and T_i is not computed. S_cM is 1.5 times Sa at the sloshing period T_c, the factor for the 0.5% damping of that mode, read log-log between the NBCC periods and held at the 10 s value beyond 10 s, which is conservative since Table 4.1.8.4.-C ends there. Then C_i = 2/3 S_aM, C_c = 2/3 S_cM and C_t = C_i (Eq 9.5a, 9.5b, 9.4.3b). Not applied: the 80% floor of 9.5, which needs the ASCE 7 values of 9.4, and the deterministic cap of 4.2.1, which can only lower the spectrum. The defaults are Vancouver, site class C, from the tool; check them against the tool for your site and designation. Why the 2/3 stays is the next question.

Why does the sheet keep ACI's 2/3 of Eq 9.5a and its I and R_wi on NBCC values?

Because ACI 350.3-20 4.2.2 defines its probabilistic spectrum as the 5% damped one with 2% in 50 years, which is what NBCC publishes, and Eq 9.5a to 9.5c apply the 2/3 to it. The 2/3 is a fixed margin and not a risk target: the 2003 NEHRP commentary sets the design ground motion at 1/1.5 of the maximum considered one for the collapse margin of structures designed to the provisions, first on these same 2% in 50 year maps, and ASCE kept it when it moved to risk-targeted values. ACI says its force levels and R factors give strength-level results like the IBC, so I from Table 4.1.1a (1.0 for risk categories I and II, 1.25 for III, 1.5 for IV) and R_wi from Table 4.1.1b (2.25 for a fixed or hinged base on grade, with R_wc 1.0 for every type) were set against the 2/3 spectrum. Keeping the 2/3 and those factors puts a tank at the demand of an ASCE 7 tank at the same hazard: NBCC Victoria Sa(0.2) is 1.30 g against Seattle S_MS of 1.365 g (Tremblay et al., 2016), so the two spectra are close. Dropping the 2/3 and keeping them would make the tank 1.5 times that; at the Vancouver defaults V goes from 545 to 818 kN and d_max from 1.18 to 1.77 m against 1.2 m of freeboard. NBCC's I_E and R_d R_o are not applied on top, which would count the importance and the ductility twice. Not settled: ACI 350.3 does not name NBCC, NBC 2020 Commentary J puts free-standing tanks outside the code and asks for ground motion consistent with it, and no Canadian source found says whether to apply the 2/3. NBC takes its margin through R_d R_o, treats the 2% in 50 year spectrum as its design level, and so loads buildings more heavily than ASCE 7. One Canadian paper (J.L. Richards, CCEE) used the NBC spectrum with no 2/3 and I_E, R_d and R_o of 1 for an elastic check of existing tanks, without discussing the factor. Confirm the choice with the owner, pick the risk category from the consequence of failure and R_wi for the base condition; the sheet looks neither up. P_c is divided by R_wc, so the default leaves the convective force unreduced.

How do I use p_iy, p_cy, p_wy and p_vy on a wall?

Not by adding them. ACI 350.3 Eq 5.3.2 combines them at each height by the square root of the sum of squares, (p_iy + p_wy), p_cy and p_vy, which is p_y; the table lists it at every height, and p_y_base and p_y_top are its two ends. Apply p_y on top of the hydrostatic q_hy: it adds on the leading wall and reduces the load on the trailing one, so design both, as the last two columns give. p_cy is linear over the whole depth while h_c is below two thirds of it and starts at the height y_cy0 above that, as R5.3.1 gives. None of it includes the dynamic earth pressure, which R5.3.2 leaves to the geotechnical engineer, and none of it enters V or M_s, which come from P_c and the other forces. Every force and pressure is per metre of tank width, since B is a unit 1 m.

What does the sloshing_freeboard_adequate check cover, and what does it leave out?

It compares h_freeboard with d_max of Eq 7.1a, (L/2) C_c I, the code's method. d_max_refined is Housner's Eq 7.1b, which the code allows in lieu of 7.1a; the commentary says 7.1a is 10 to 20% greater than the exact results, but 7.1b is only 4% lower at the defaults and can be the larger at small L / h_fluid, so read it beside d_max and do not take it as the lower bound. It has no solution once C_c reaches 0.633 / tanh(3.16 h_fluid / L), and then it repeats Eq 7.1a. ACI 350.3 does not fix a freeboard: where overtopping is tolerable it asks for none, and otherwise for freeboard, a roof designed for the uplift, or a spillway. On a covered tank whose freeboard is below d_max / I, p_roof is the R7.1 uplift pressure, C_LF gamma_fluid (d_max / I - h_o), on the length L_i of roof at each end wall. The commentary leaves C_LF to the engineer between 1.4 and 3.2, and 2.2 is its compromise. Left out: the confined sloshing mass that R7.1 adds to the impulsive mass, the corner sloshing it raises by SRSS of both directions, which needs the tank's other dimension, and any freeboard rule of the owner.

Revision history

After an independent checker's review: response modification inputs are limited to what Table 4.1.1b gives a rectangular tank (R_wc of 1.0, R_wi at most 3.25), S_aM takes the greatest of Sa(0.2), Sa(0.5) and 0.9 of the longer-period peak, L over fluid depth outside 0.5 to 8 is refused, and an open tank takes no roof weight
ValueWasNowUnit
rho_c2402.37kg⋅m−3\mathrm{kg} \cdot \mathrm{m}^{-3}
rho_L1000.31kg⋅m−3\mathrm{kg} \cdot \mathrm{m}^{-3}
W_bottom0kN\mathrm{kN}
m_w16161.9kg⋅m−1\mathrm{kg} \cdot \mathrm{m}^{-1}
m_i45251.9kg⋅m−1\mathrm{kg} \cdot \mathrm{m}^{-1}